It took David Cavanagh just over two years to create this book.
During that time, he spoke to over two hundred people and wrote close to 400,000 words. It was a Herculean task, and as he became more and more immersed in it, those of us who knew him wondered how he was managing, and whether what he had taken on would ever reach its end. Once or twice a week, he would arrive at the office of Select, the music magazine where I worked, and ask if he could once again use our archive for some bit of research or other, a ritual that seemed to go on for endless months.
When he began, in 1997, British music and its surrounding culture were moving into the last stages of a chapter that had started three years before. The international media was getting very worked up about ‘Cool Britannia’, a giddy and celebratory vision of the UK that had first stirred in the form of Britpop. The Labour Party had just won its first general election in eighteen years, and records made by what Cavanagh memorably termed ‘four or more pale boys with hurt feelings’ were still selling in their millions. Creation Records, the company whose story he had decided to tell, seemed to be at the core of all this: its big release that year was the third Oasis album, Be Here Now, and the company’s founder and self-styled president, Alan McGee, had become a high-profile Labour Party donor, influential associate of Tony Blair and champion of something called ‘the creative industries’.
By the end of 1999, that moment had unravelled. The image of Britain – and London in particular – as a pop-cultural hotbed had palled, and any lingering idea of Blair as a rock ’n’ roll prime minister seemed laughably passé. Britpop was dead and buried, and the over-produced, pompous Be Here Now had shown that Oasis were now past their prime. ‘Indie’ had once been short for ‘independent’, and denoted music that had inherited at least some attitude and counter-cultural oomph from punk; now it meant bland attractions such as Coldplay, Travis and the Stereophonics. Most strikingly of all, Creation was no more, having been brought to a sudden end by a man who had chased success and then embraced it, but afterwards found himself in the company of people he neither liked nor understood. ‘In 1993, it was my gang,’ said McGee. ‘And by 1999, it was someone else’s gang. I felt as if I was running Railtrack. I’d nothing in common with the people I worked with.’
For Cavanagh, deep into a book that had long since taken over a large chunk of his life, these developments were very helpful. His history of Creation now had a definite conclusion, and an equally clear narrative arc. Like most great music stories, the essential plotline was Faustian. As well as music, it involved drugs, money, volatile personalities and vivid tales that often reflected the same essential theme: how success, or at least the prospect of it, affects the artistic impulse and people’s relationships.
When the book finally appeared, its cover featured an instantly familiar photograph of McGee and Noel Gallagher – both dressed in suits – greeting Tony Blair at a Downing Street reception, a mocked-up Creation credit card and two piles of cocaine. The question such imagery posed was obvious: how had that happened? Much of Cavanagh’s story, after all, centred on an aesthetic ideal that could not have been more different. In its purest iteration, the Creation mindset was about leather jackets, Breton shirts, Syd Barrett, the Velvet Underground, the lingering influence of punk rock, and a dingy kind of hedonism. When music had been upturned by acid house, McGee and his allies had soaked up new, vivid colours and textures, and acquired an even stronger fondness for excess, but the basic components of their vision had survived. But in the era of Britpop, even if McGee and his allies did their best to hang on to the label’s founding ideas, the outward appearance of the label and its world had been transformed.
Creation had first come to life in the upstairs room of the Adams Arms, a pub near the Post Office Tower where McGee had put on a weekly night called the Living Room. Less than fifteen years later, the logo of a company that was by then half owned by the Sony corporation was draped on a huge hospitality tent, erected for two nights when Oasis played to 250,000 people at Knebworth Park in Hertfordshire. Creation would go on for another three and a half years, but the tensions and contradictions swirling around the label led inexorably to McGee’s decision to bring everything to a stop. Music was by then operating according to a drastically changed set of rules and ideas, which Cavanagh captured in his elegant, definitive prose. ‘In the twenty-first-century music business at least, stories of independence are history,’ he wrote. ‘In every sense of the word.’
At least half of My Magpie Eyes Are Hungry for the Prize is an evocation of a world that is now almost unimaginable. A lot of the action takes place in a London that has disappeared: recording studios where everything had to stop whenever a train rumbled past; musicians who lived in horrible squats; bohemian small businesses that were constantly on the verge of insolvency – and, perhaps most fascinatingly, occasions when bands and musicians would approach each other in a spirit of mutual antipathy, if not outright loathing. The world was less cluttered with distractions back then, and in ways no one could ever quite predict, music could take on a level of significance that sometimes caused people to fight each other.
These tensions were reflected in a music industry cleaved by a huge gap. On one side were the major record labels, whose peak moment arrived with Live Aid, the global event that enshrined a new musical aristocracy: U2, Queen, Sting, Madonna, Dire Straits. The antithesis of all this was represented by the independent companies, who were shut out of the world Live Aid embodied, and usually seemed more than happy to be excluded. But as the 1980s went on, these two camps increasingly intersected – and by the time of Britpop, they would verge on the indistinguishable. This was probably the key cultural story of the era that stretched into the early 2000s: insiders becoming outsiders and having to adjust to experiences they had never expected. In that sense, though this is a book about music, it is also a fascinating work of social history.
David Cavanagh was born in Dublin in 1964 and brought up in Belfast.
He was then a student at University College London’s School of Slavonic and Eastern European Studies, where he completed a degree in Russian and Serbo-Croat. He did his first professional writing for the music weekly Sounds, and by the late 1980s, he was close to being considered its pre-eminent writer. He then moved to the newly launched monthly Select, where he was a dedicated mentor to new talent, carefully guiding a handful of protégés through the mechanics of writing and the etiquette of the music business.
Four years after his death, it is clearer than ever that Cavanagh was one of the greatest-ever writers to devote their work to music and its attendant dramas (and comedies). After Sounds and Select, he wrote features and reviews for Q, Uncut and Mojo – publications where he developed his talent for explaining and exploring records and live performances, and evoking the lives of the people at the heart of them. In person, he could be either withdrawn and taciturn or animated and very funny. Somehow, the best of his writing combined both these facets: he described musicians with an acuity that suggested the perspective of a silent observer, but his prose was always laced with a dry wit – and a striking talent for capturing why particular bands or records were as brilliant as he thought.
His writing was always crisp and economical.
Cavanagh was full of passion for his subject, but he also wrote like a grown-up, spurning the kind of faux academic waffle that was de rigueur in certain corners of the music press and using small observations to weave big, dramatic stories. Like many of the best writers, he also had an innate, almost neurotic drive to ensure that everything was done properly. His copy was always delivered free of mistakes. Facts were always checked. Like a lot of the people who read his work, he was fastidious and obsessive. But at the same time, he always had a keen appreciation for the messy, human aspects of the world he moved in, and the fascinating things that tend to happen when creative people are thrown together.
My Magpie Eyes Are Hungry for the Prize is built from these elements. Its best stories are about individuals from more or less ordinary backgrounds who saw in music a chance to reinvent themselves. McGee’s rise to prominence is a perfect case in point. ‘I had red hair with freckles, and glasses,’ he told Cavanagh. ‘Women were so far off my agenda they didn’t even come into it.’ In his home city of Glasgow, he latched on to punk rock ‘with the darting eyes and dry mouth of the galvanised latecomer’, and then ducked and dived his way through London, where he first worked as a clerk for British Rail. Whereas many of the people who ran the capital’s ‘indie’ labels felt a strong sense of common cause, McGee always seemed different. ‘Alan never wanted to be small fry,’ one of his associates told Cavanagh. ‘He was a rough kid from Glasgow and he wanted to succeed in his own right.’
Early on, Cavanagh brilliantly portrays the Jesus and Mary Chain, three misfits from the Scottish new town of East Kilbride who were reputed to spend fourteen hours a day watching television, and who gave McGee and Creation their first taste of notoriety. The music writer David Quantick described their initial sound as being akin to ‘a giant bee in a ventilator shaft’. On their first British tour, Cavanagh wrote, ‘The performance would consist of sheer malign noise, the aural equivalent of a stroboscope. Once it was over, the audience would be at cross purposes with itself: angry because the gig was terrible, and furious that there had not been more of it.’ In March 1985, this was the clash of reactions that led to the so-called riot at the Polytechnic of North London, which allowed McGee to infuse Creation’s reputation with a certain malevolence, a quality that stuck.
Soon after, McGee began his working relationship with the House of Love, a fleetingly brilliant rock group built around two combustible personalities: Guy Chadwick, the stridently ambitious son of a British army colonel who knew the band was his last shot at success; and Terry Bickers, the band’s much younger lead guitarist, full of the kind of sensitivity and brilliance that often blurs into mental fragility. In 1988, Cavanagh had reviewed their first album in Sounds and captured the magic they momentarily possessed:
It’s one of those records that seem to enter your body throat first. This is not so much due to Guy Chadwick’s rich pale moan, or even the lyrics of ‘deep blue seas and impossible dreams’ he seems to write in his sleep, but to Terry Bickers’ catalogue of guitar vibrations, shrieks, pistol whips and immolations. He claims not to be able to play. As long as he keeps thinking that, fine.
They started in ’87 with ‘Shine On’, the best flop ever. Following it with ‘Real Animal’ and ‘Christine’, one mesmerising, the other enchanting, they said it loud, proud and with a poetic flourish. And in a very English way, too. On the cover of this album three of the blurred faces appear to be trying to remember the words to their favourite Shakespeare quote.
The relationship between Bickers and Chadwick snapped under the pressure of huge commercial expectations and the equally vast amounts of money spent on them by the major-label Phonogram, thanks to a record deal that McGee had secured. Poetically, Cavanagh’s telling of their story reached its watershed point at a service station on the English/Welsh border, in the wake of a magic mushroom binge, where, as he accused the band’s drummer, Pete Evans, of not giving enough of his income to charity, Bickers set fire to a banknote. Evans then ‘punched Bickers half a dozen times in the face’, but Bickers ‘did not feel any of the blows land’. Bickers was then summarily sacked – and in terms of a spectacular squandering of promise and potential, that was that.
The book’s other stars are My Bloody Valentine, and their singular, deeply eccentric leader Kevin Shields, whose approach to live performance was at least partly triggered by the London ‘in’ crowd’s initial response to his group. Here was a confrontational attitude similar to the one adopted by the Mary Chain, but this time taken to another level. ‘Shields liked to use frequencies that damaged people’s hearing,’ Cavanagh wrote. ‘It was not altogether clear whether this was sonic pranksterism gone mad, or a studied act of revenge by My Bloody Valentine on a generation that had banished them.’
Shields’ wayward instincts were always going to test even the most generous benefactor, and so it proved: his group’s 1991 album Loveless almost bankrupted Creation, and the final calamity happened when McGee was forced to borrow £22,000 from his father to secure the record’s master tapes. This was money that had been paid out in life insurance when McGee’s mother had died, which is not the kind of thing that usually brings an artist and their mentor closer together.
In the wake of the release of Loveless, My Bloody Valentine set out on a UK tour. The watershed point of their performances was a section known as ‘The Holocaust’: an extended passage during ‘You Made Me Realise’ in which Shields and his co-guitarist Bilinda Butcher would lead the band into noise so loud that it would sometimes cause objects to move and people to vomit and faint. Here, Cavanagh’s ability to evoke weird turns of events using the most straightforward words comes into its own. ‘Shields and Butcher would stare at faces in the front rows, monitoring the gradual changes,’ he wrote. ‘Shields was amused by the idea that the audience was afraid the ceiling was about to collapse . . . Shields’ right hand appeared to make the male masturbatory gesture as it stroked the holocaustal chord. And as a point of interest, when the concert was over Shields did not say goodnight. He said “goodbye”.’
Until the arrival of Oasis, most of Creation’s stories played out in front of comparatively small audiences and involved musicians who were nowhere near being household names. Part of the achievement of this book is the way that its author writes about its main characters in terms of immense drama and significance, even though most of the events they were involved in were known only to readers of the weekly music press, at most. There is something audacious about that: aware that most of music’s myths and legends have been repeated to death, Cavanagh took his opportunity to create a few new ones, and because he was such a talented writer, he pulled it off.
The single best example focuses on the Loft, another volatile quartet, centred on the singer and songwriter Pete Astor (born Pete Astor-Smith, and known at school by the latter surname alone, before he decided ‘to reinvent myself and have a glamorous name’). The Loft were the creators of ‘Up the Hill and Down the Slope’, the Creation single whose lyrics gave Cavanagh the title for his book. The time Astor, Andy Strickland, Bill Prince and Dave Morgan spent together was brief; their recorded output extended to two singles, and they played their final gig in 1985, an episode that Cavanagh recounted as if he were describing something mythic. ‘Astor looked first at Prince, then at Strickland, said, “Bad luck,” and dropped his guitar on the ground,’ he wrote. ‘The audience watched him walk up the staircase at the back of the stage – like Sinatra – to the dressing room.’ With a friend, Strickland quickly hatched a plan to ambush Astor and beat him up, but the chance never came. The drama and bathos of this story suggests something from a biography of the Byrds, or the Clash, or even the Rolling Stones: you forget that you are actually reading about a very obscure band doing a support slot at the Hammersmith Palais. But that was a token of Cavanagh’s talent, and the way that he could always call on the perspective of an awestruck fan.
As Creation reached its commercial peak in the mid-1990s, the idea of a definitive book about the label and its founder was conceived by Ian Gittins, a former Melody Maker writer who had become an editor at Virgin books, who then took a proposal to McGee.
Gittins suggested Cavanagh as a possible author, McGee agreed, and a deal was quickly concluded. For the duration of the time Cavanagh spent writing it, My Magpie Eyes Are Hungry for the Prize was understood as official history, which opened the way to interviews with all the relevant Creation insiders.
Cavanagh was initially given nine months to finish his work, but he then asked for two years. The agreed advance was £25,000. Writers receive such payments in three separate chunks: one when a book’s contract is signed; another upon delivery of the manuscript; and the last when the book is finally published. That meant Cavanagh was paid just over £8,000 during twenty-four months of immensely hard work. In that sense, the book was an archetypal labour of love. What else could it have been?
‘Fifteen or eighteen months in,’ Gittins later told me, ‘McGee started phoning me up, saying, “I’m not sure about the way this book’s going.”’
His complaint was that Cavanagh was coming to him with reams of questions, often about the fine details of Creation’s history. ‘What he wanted, obviously, was a book about this mad genius from Glasgow who sets up this crazy label, takes loads of drugs and signs all these brilliant bands,’ Gittins said. ‘And Cavanagh wasn’t writing that book. He was writing a definitive, very detailed study of the label, which is what he was commissioned to do.’
When McGee was sent the final manuscript – which, prior to editing, was around a fifth longer than the final version – he asked for only a single line to be excised. But just as the book was finally published, he began loudly expressing his displeasure. Cavanagh, he said, had written ‘the accountant’s tale’, and his work was nothing less than ‘objectionable’. McGee quickly commissioned another book about Creation, by the music writer Paolo Hewitt. In 2010, there was an authorised documentary, titled Upside Down; around a decade later, McGee’s own memoir, Creation Stories, was turned into a very entertaining comedy–drama by the actor and director Nick Moran. Both are worth watching. But as an account of Creation and the huge cultural changes it embodied, Cavanagh’s book remains unrivalled and authoritative, hardly short of the kind of romance McGee obviously saw in his own story, but also staunchly anchored in fact.
Cavanagh wrote two more books. In 2003, a solitary novel, Music for Boys, tapped into his adolescence in Northern Ireland. A brilliantly executed book about John Peel, Good Night and Good Riddance, published twelve years later, was a chronological account of over two hundred of Peel’s programmes and stood as a kind of alternative history of post-Beatles music. Meanwhile, Cavanagh’s writing continued to appear in the magazines whose features and reviews had always given him a perfect stage. There was something about the way such publications worked that always suited him: a phone call, a commission, and a week or two to turn a piece round, during which he would often come up with strikingly fresh insights and perspectives on whatever he was writing about. I have been fortunate enough to work with a lot of very talented people, but I cannot think of anyone whose pieces could trigger quite the same feeling of anticipation.
Towards the end of his work on this book, he surfaced to write a piece for a Q magazine special on Bob Dylan that I was editing. I asked him to choose a Dylan album other than one of the supposed classics, and he picked the unloved in-concert album Before the Flood, released in 1974. What he handed in forcefully made the case for a record he saw as a stunning example of live rock music and an extended yell of defiance in an era of decadence and laziness. ‘It’s the penultimate song on the album, “Like a Rolling Stone”, that has the most cut-throat vehemence,’ he wrote. ‘A predictable crowd pleaser if ever there was one, it is performed with anything but complacency – there is none of the conspiratorial, here’s-one-from-when-we-were-all-young-and-foolish smugness that befell artists and audiences alike elsewhere in that decade. The verses are punched out, incrimination by incrimination. The four-man choruses are all but screamed. The next time people heard music this bilious, it was being made by The Clash.’ The album, he said, was the ‘sound of crackling fire, damned insubordination and bloodshot rock’n’roll, and that sound is none the quieter after 26 years.’
In 2016, amid the great ocean of cant and cliché that followed the death of David Bowie, he wrote a long obituary for Uncut. It was full of singular reflections, not least his observation that Bowie’s songs had always been full of intimations of mortality and a sense of finite time:
Aged only 25, he gave the Earth just five years to survive in The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars. Six months earlier (‘Changes’), he’d warned the insouciant exemplars of teenage virility (‘look out, you rock’n’rollers’) that the ageing process would begin sooner than they expected . . . In 1971, in ‘Kooks’, he counselled his son Zowie, newly born and in his crib, to blow his trumpet and face down his bullies while he still had the power of innocence in his lungs. ‘Soon you’ll grow . . .’
He also perfectly captured how much Bowie had changed the world:
Down here among the damned . . . we have to get used to not having him around again. Bowie’s ‘anthems for the alienated’, as someone alliteratively called them the other day, have played all day and all night at shrines in London and Berlin, in bedroom shrines, in private. The memories and confessions will always pour out. There was a unity in the prayer of his songs. He made it all right to be an outsider, they say, but look around. Look at the millions of outsiders. No wonder Bowie found it easy to disappear on the pavements of Manhattan. All those Bowies, just like him.
One of this best-ever feats of writing and interviewing appeared in the summer of 2018, when Mojo sent him to Liverpool to meet Ian McCulloch – after forty years, still the singer and leader of Echo and the Bunnymen. Here was another story about success, and having to adjust to life after it. The two of them spent a day and a half together – enough time for Cavanagh to get a strong sense of how McCulloch interacted with his home environment and his own myth. A few passages prove the point:
‘There he is,’ a voice pipes up behind us. ‘The lead singer of The Cure. Look at the state of him. Remember when he was famous in the ’80s?’ McCulloch turns and ruefully acknowledges the insult. There’s a group of them, snow-white-haired Scouse men in their sixties, drinking at the corner table. We get a couple of pints and go and stand in the corridor. It’s a Friday afternoon, the rain has stopped and the pub is rammed. McCulloch seems preoccupied. He’s been blind-sided by the Cure comment. As put-downs go, it was a good one, and he needs time to think of his response. Just as oceanic rock music is where McCulloch finds his element, so is a Liverpool pub full of hardened drinkers and acidic wits.
We sit in silence. I look around at the blue guitar, the flat screen and the teddy bear. Somewhere in the house, armies of unseen ants form themselves into battalions. And in the midst of it all, smoking Marlboros on a bed at four in the morning, is a man looking for something to love him back.
McCulloch is up at 11.30am, pottering around in shorts and pouring himself a brandy. He felt a bit rough earlier, but his hangover cure – a Berocca and a cigarette – has worked nicely. As we sit down for our final interview, something explodes in the fly-killing machine, making a bang like an amplified mousetrap. ‘That’s the sound!’ cries McCulloch, slapping the table in delight. ‘That. Is. The. Sound.’
Around six months after that article was published, Cavanagh ended his own life at a railway station in Bedfordshire. There were tributes and obituaries, but inevitably, other people’s prose could not capture his talent nearly as well as his own work. Those of us who avidly followed his writing sorely miss him. At his best, there was no one who could get near his combination of abilities: to tell human stories, to alert his readers to qualities they had probably missed in music they loved, to introduce them to stuff they didn’t know, and to get to the heart of the strange magic that we occasionally glimpse at gigs and hear in records.
My Magpie Eyes Are Hungry for the Prize is one of his masterpieces. If you want to conclusively understand what music can mean to people, start here.
John Harris, September 2022
The Creation Records Story: My Magpie Eyes are Hungry for the Prize by David Cavanagh is out now in paperback and ebook.
Out of print for many years and regarded as one of the greatest music books ever written, My Magpie Eyes are Hungry for the Prize: The Creation Records Story is the definitive account of the iconic British record label, republished for the label’s 40th anniversary.